View Full Version : Brothers study session questions
02-03-2005, 02:42 PM
during our study sessions we encountered some holes in our notes
inshAllah these were the questoins we had
-what was the conclusion of issue #2
-do 2 qullas equal 500 lbs of water
-is it recommended to not urinate in running water
-what is the title of the book of ibn al-Mundhir quoted from on page 11 of the binder
-what was the strongest opinion for issue #6
-what was the strongest opinion for issue #7
-what was the conclusion for issue #9
02-08-2005, 07:19 PM
a few more questions we encountered:
what was the strongest opinion for issue #14 for purification
and what happens if a person sees water during prayer if they have tayammum, is their prayer broken?
02-08-2005, 10:03 PM
Asalamu alaikum, here are the answers to some of these questions from my notes (these could be wrong, and I would double check with Shaikh Abdul Bary):
Issue #2 (Used water): The strongest opinion is that it is pure unless proven otherwise.
Ibn al-Mundhir wrote a book on ijma’ (consensus), but I don’t know the title or if it is existence today.
Issue #6 (Animal dung/urine): Strongest opinion is that of Imam Ahmad, that if its meat is halal, its urine/dung also pure.
Issue #7 (Purity of semen): The strongest opinion is in favor of its purity.
Issue #9 (vessels of non-Muslims): Strongest opinion is that it is not permissible to use them unless no alternatives exist.
Issue #14 (Touching the Private Parts): The strongest opinion is that of the majority, namely, that touching the genitals does break your wudu.
02-17-2005, 05:38 PM
during our study sessions we encountered a few more questions:
what is Qunut alAa'rida and what is Qunut anNawwazil
also if you do sajdah asSahwi because you have added something to the prayer so you make it after the tasleem but do you do the tasleem another time after the sajdah
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2013, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.