Imam Malik's proof?

AssalamuAlaikum,

In my notes I have that Imam Malik's opinion (or one narration...?) was that it is not even permissible for an Imam to lead if he has to sit. (Sitting Imam not allowed). What was the proof for this, since all the proofs given in class were regarding situations where Imams were seated?

I think he just had an opinion about it, he didn't give us the proof but he gave us a reason.

Malik says that it's not permissible for the Imam to sit in the first place.

Reason: For example if the Imam is chronically ill then you should get another person who can stand to prevent future fitnah for the kids who grow up seeing that.

Maybe he didn't mention the proof because Imam Malik didn't have any? Allahu 3lam

Originally Posted by AlMurabit

I think he just had an opinion about it, he didn't give us the proof but he gave us a reason.

Malik says that it's not permissible for the Imam to sit in the first place.

Reason: For example if the Imam is chronically ill then you should get another person who can stand to prevent future fitnah for the kids who grow up seeing that.

Maybe he didn't mention the proof because Imam Malik didn't have any? Allahu 3lam

Yes, I had this reason in the notes too, but it seemed strange to me because wasn't it Imam Malik who said leaning during the actual prayer or using things in prayer for support was ok? So then if he said an Imam that can not stand must not lead the prayer...is it contradictory? (Or actually, maybe because one CAN lean during prayer--he should use any means possible first..and be Imam as a LAST resort...?)...Subhana'Allah I have so little knowledge, its too overwhelming.